These are really three different issues: 1) The CEO compensation; 2) Commission/P&L bonuses of profitable employees; 3) Misaligned compensation packages of the CDO/mortgage-backed buying managers.
The first one is a symbolic issue (and is irrelevant IMO) and the second one is perfectly appropriate — its the 3rd one that has become so problematic.
>
2007senior-officer bonuses*/ total bonus pools**
|
Bailout money
|
2008
Bonus Pools |
|
Merrill Lynch
|
$85M/$9.5B
|
$10B
|
Reportedly, in December, just before Bank of America took over, John Thain quietly awarded $3 to $4 billion in bonuses, a month earlier than was customary.
|
Bank of America
|
$36M/$11.3B
|
$15B
|
The company granted 2008 retention bonuses to 6,200 Merrill brokers, and C.E.O. Ken Lewis declined to answer a question about this year’s bonuses at a shareholder meeting in December.
|
Goldman Sachs
|
$313M/$12.1B
|
$10B
|
Average compensation is reportedly down 45 percent in 2008 but will actually be a greater share of revenues than in 2007.
|
Morgan Stanley
|
$64M/$9.9B
|
$10B
|
The firm’s 2008 bonus pool is down 50 percent but is still estimated at $5 billion.
|
Citigroup
|
$54M/$20.7B
|
$45B
|
The ratio of compensation to revenues is reportedly not remarkably different for 2008.
|
Wells Fargo
|
$40M/$8B
|
$25B
|
C.E.O. John Stumpf and top executives have not said they will forgo their 2008 bonuses as of mid-January.
|
J. P. Morgan Chase
|
$91M/$13.6B
|
$25B
|
While net income was down 64 percent in 2008, bonuses are reported to be down only 30 to 50 percent.
|
Total
|
$683M/$85.1B
|
$140B
|
|
*Total of top five bonus packages (including stocks) received by highest-ranking officers.
**Estimated as 60 percent of compensation where exact figures are not available. |
>
Source:
Bonus Babies: The Big Tarp Recipients and their Booty
Christopher Bateman
Vanity Fair, February 2, 2009, 10:00 AM
http://www.vanityfair.com/online/politics/2009/02/bonus-babies-the-big-tarp-recipients-and-their-booty.html
Wall Street’s $18.4 Billion Bonus
Michael Shnayerson
Vanity Fair, March 2009
http://www.vanityfair.com/politics/features/2009/03/wall-street-bonuses200903
What's been said:
Discussions found on the web: