Spain’s Banks & Markets
David R. Kotok
June 10, 2012
Eurozone leaders rose to the occasion. They had no choice. The Spanish bailout means Europe will not permit “runs” to sink their banking system.
Notice how we have not seen TV coverage of a eurozone version of the “Northern Rock Affair.” For those who do not remember that event, it was the run on a British bank that caused the bank to fail when depositors demanded their money. That triggered a panic. Disaster was averted by prompt action from the Bank of England.
Think about it. Greek banks have lost tens of billions of euros in deposits and yet there have been no failures. Cyprus is bleeding deposits but no failures. Other countries, too. The Spanish deposit flight has been huge.
Yet, there are no reported failures to pay euro depositors who demand their money.
You cannot blame the depositors for seeking safety by moving their money to German, Dutch, or Finnish banks. I would. You would. We advised some clients to do so. Euros are euros regardless of which bank holds them for you. Why take a risk with your deposit under the present circumstances, when you can avoid it.
The euro system leadership knows that bank runs can cause their 17-country, currency-zone system to collapse. All of banking history is supportive of this fact. Therefore, they faced the issue when their backs were to the wall.
The fact is the absence of banking collapses is good news. That is correct. Good news! We establish that good news by what we DO NOT see on TV. We do not see banks collapsing and failing to pay depositors. This means we may not witness the euro system collapsing and failing.
Bank runs and deposit failures are symptoms of liquidity constraints. Liquidity is not to be confused with solvency. A prime example: Greece is certainly insolvent. It cannot pay its debt or its governmental bills. Nevertheless, Greece’s banks still have liquidity because of Emergency Liquidity Assistance (ELA) funding. ELA exists the euro system agents know that they cannot permit euro system banks to fail to pay their depositors.
Therefore, our conclusion is that liquidity issues will be addressed in the euro zone. The Spanish banking chapter is unfolding before our eyes. Markets have been pricing in a fear of systemic failure on the liquidity side. Market bears will be disappointed, because the liquidity failure is not going to happen.
Other market agents have priced the solvency issue correctly. That is why the Greek stock market has been decimated. That is why Greek bonds trade with astronomical yields. That is why Spanish stocks are down. That is why credit spreads are so wide. See www.cumber.com for updated spreads in Europe.
Europe can fix or stopgap any illiquidity. They have the tools with the various funding sources like ESM, with the ELA and with the hands of the European Central Bank (ECB).
The solvency issue requires governments with strong leadership and durable commitments to change behaviors. As we know from our own political experience in the US, this solvency/debt issue is much harder to tackle.
Central bankers and institutions around the world have the ability to offset liquidity crunches. They know that another Lehman/AIG moment cannot be permitted. Do they have the ability to deal with insolvency? On that one, the jury is still out.
We remain positive on markets; we are underweight Europe and we favor the US. We do not expect a market meltdown arising out of liquidity constraints. We remain nervously and fully invested in our US ETF accounts.
We worry about solvency. That is the political side of the issue, and we are not in the least sanguine about politicians in any country, including our own. European politicians caused European government insolvency. Can they fix it? We shall find out in due time. The next test is coming on June 17, with French and Greek elections.
David R. Kotok, Chairman and Chief Investment Officer