No Discounting? Boy, that was quick.
I cannot recall the last time a common “meme” was so quickly proven to be false in the financial markets and/or analyst community. As mentioned here yesterday , I do not believe that retailers would win their game of chicken, holding out as long as possible before slashing prices to spur sales.
Now, a FULL WEEK BEFORE Thanksgiving, Wal-Mart (WMT) has looked into the eyes of their fellow retailers and called their bluff: the retailing giant has fired a broadside — not a shot across the bow, but a fusillade into the flank of the not-so-good ship Toys-R-Us (TOY). Upping the ante from previous price cuts, Wal-Mart will press their specialty adversaries on price while they are somewhat vulnerable to margin compression.
To WMT, they — apparently — couldn’t care less about Toy margins. They simply want to bring customers into the store, margins be damned. To Toys-R- US, the X-mas season is 40% (or more) of their year’s sales. A bruising fight will hurt revenues, margins, profits, and ultimately their stock price and market cap.
Here’s an excerpt from this morn’s WSJ:
Wal-Mart Stores Inc. has launched the Great Toy War of 2003 and its top soldier is Hokey Pokey Elmo.
In late September, a full three months before Christmas, and a month before hot holiday items normally are promoted, Wal-Mart Stores slashed the price on Fisher-Price’s newest dancing doll to $19.46 — a stunning 22% discount to the Toys “R” Us price of $24.99.
Then, by mid-October, Wal-Mart had cut prices on more than a dozen toys. A survey of the prices for 15 popular toys conducted by Banc of America Securities found that Wal-Mart’s prices were 12% cheaper than Toys “R” Us and 8% less than prices at discount retailer Target.
The steep and early price cuts are roiling the industry. Tuesday, Toys “R” Us acknowledged Wal-Mart’s moves caught it by surprise and hurt its third-quarter results. Its stock price fell 5.4% Tuesday in New York Stock Exchange composite trading, after falling 11% Monday when company’s earnings came out.
While parents may love the lower prices, other competitors are frustrated, saying they are hard-pressed to match prices below their costs. Yet they can’t afford to lose more market share to Wal-Mart . And manufacturers fret that the discounting will cheapen their brand names, quash innovation and prompt consumers to buy only when toys are on sale . . .”
On Wall Street, beware of Analysts bearing wishful thinking — its a sure path to the poor house . . .
Wal-Mart Fires the First Shot In Holiday-Toy Pricing War
By Ann Zimmerman, Joseph Pereira and Queena Sook Kim
Wall Street Journal, November 19, 2003
Wal-Mart kicks off toy price war
Report: No. 1 retailer slashes tags on popular and hard-to-find items, surprising Toys “R” Us.
CNN/Money November 19, 2003
Toys ‘R’ Us to Close 180 Stores
it’s not in argument but it might interest you http://straitstimes.asia1.com.sg/commentary/story/0,4386,221870,00.html?