Here Comes the Economic Stimulus!
March 14, 2008 4:00pm by Barry Ritholtz
This content, which contains security-related opinions and/or information, is provided for informational purposes only and should not be relied upon in any manner as professional advice, or an endorsement of any practices, products or services. There can be no guarantees or assurances that the views expressed here will be applicable for any particular facts or circumstances, and should not be relied upon in any manner. You should consult your own advisers as to legal, business, tax, and other related matters concerning any investment. The commentary in this “post” (including any related blog, podcasts, videos, and social media) reflects the personal opinions, viewpoints, and analyses of the Ritholtz Wealth Management employees providing such comments, and should not be regarded the views of Ritholtz Wealth Management LLC. or its respective affiliates or as a description of advisory services provided by Ritholtz Wealth Management or performance returns of any Ritholtz Wealth Management Investments client. References to any securities or digital assets, or performance data, are for illustrative purposes only and do not constitute an investment recommendation or offer to provide investment advisory services. Charts and graphs provided within are for informational purposes solely and should not be relied upon when making any investment decision. Past performance is not indicative of future results. The content speaks only as of the date indicated. Any projections, estimates, forecasts, targets, prospects, and/or opinions expressed in these materials are subject to change without notice and may differ or be contrary to opinions expressed by others. The Compound Media, Inc., an affiliate of Ritholtz Wealth Management, receives payment from various entities for advertisements in affiliated podcasts, blogs and emails. Inclusion of such advertisements does not constitute or imply endorsement, sponsorship or recommendation thereof, or any affiliation therewith, by the Content Creator or by Ritholtz Wealth Management or any of its employees. Investments in securities involve the risk of loss. For additional advertisement disclaimers see here: https://www.ritholtzwealth.com/advertising-disclaimers Please see disclosures here: https://ritholtzwealth.com/blog-disclosures/
What's been said:
Discussions found on the web:Posted Under
Previous Post
Headline of the Day: S&P Cuts Bear Stearns’ RatingNext Post
Friday Night Jazz: Andreas Vollenweider
Uhhh, I don’t get it.
Just kidding. I do – sort of – but wouldn’t the black lightning bolt representing oil px’s have been better as, say, an arrow set to pierce the balloon? Or how about an arrow representing inflation generally? Oil isn’t the only obstacle we face.
An okay cartoon, perhaps, but not a great cartoon.
My $.02.
6-12 months from now you will look back at today’s market hysteria and ask: “What was I thinking? It was unreal buying opportunity but I was shorting/selling”
P.S. Do not delete this post and lets come back to it in 6-12 months
OMG!!!! Marketpalce has your quote on the front page about the BS building (he said BS, HEHEHE). And coming from someone of your stature. That’s right up there with the remark a couple of years back about the monkeys screaming and throwing feces….
a great laugh to end the week, tanks a milliones
Barry – I’ve gotta wonder whether nosebleed oil prices are the requirement for the oil producing countries remaining with the dollar standard?? Yes, I know this sounds paranoid, but the dollar has little else going for it nowadays besides its ubiquity.
Barton Biggs Expects 1,000-Point Gain in Dow as Fear Recedes
By Brian Sullivan and Michael Patterson
March 14 (Bloomberg) — The decline in U.S. stocks is “way overdone” and the Dow Jones Industrial Average may rally 1,000 points, investor Barton Biggs said.
“We’re in a financial panic,” Biggs said during a telephone interview with Bloomberg Television from New York. “We’re setting up for a really big rally. I don’t mean three or four hundred points on the Dow, I mean 1,000 points on the Dow. I don’t know if we’re going to get it next week or the week after. But this thing has gotten crazy and is overdone.”
Biggs, a former Morgan Stanley strategist who now runs the $1.5 billion hedge fund Traxis Partners LLC, said “this is the time to be buying stocks around the world and not to be selling them.”
The Dow average has tumbled 16 percent since reaching a record in October.
“I can’t get wildly bearish,” Biggs said. “This is not the end of the world.”
________________________________________________
It makes sense. Thanks Barton!
High oil prices do 3 things
As previously indicated, it keeps most of OPEC and Big Oil happy with the dollar.
Those countries who import oil, while not happy with the dollar, need the dollar to buy oil, so they accumulate them. This is weakened a bit by Russia, Venezuela and Iran selling oil in other currencies.
Those bankers who make money creating money (M3 is increasing at 16%) are happy, as they can create money for the oil consuming countries like China who need dollars, via consumer debt that allows us to buy their goods. The consumer is hurting though.
So whats up with the dollar? Might be that folks have lost confidence in the ability of the consumer to keep feeding the machine, and demand for dollars is weakening with more oil being sold off the dollar.
The fleas (bankers) have killed “Consumer” the dog, and so goes the dollar. May you RIP Consumer, you were loyal to the end, and you will be missed. Maybe if we can catch the fleas like we caught Spitzer there will be justice, but the fleas might have been responsible for Spitzer demise, so don’t count on it.
“Biggs, a former Morgan Stanley strategist who now runs the $1.5 billion hedge fund Traxis Partners LLC, said “this is the time to be buying stocks around the world and not to be selling them.”
________
Biggs then mentioned that his company was out of cash due to its poor investment strategy, and tried to borrow a 5 spot for a double venti latte.
to Biggs credit, it makes a lot more sense to buy after a 20 – 25% correction in the S&P, Nasdaq then to buy after a 20% run up doesn’t it?
I mean, let’s face the facts. This won’t go on forever (bear markets NEVER do). However, for now I’m definitely staying defensive with SDS, QID, FXP, EFU and IAU. Hope to just tred water until at least the credit/bank crisis is behind us (probably in the 4th or 5th inning by now).
Anyone disagree?
Biggs took the wrong side of the oil trade early on and it cost him a ton. If ytou’re looking for a timing gure, he is not it.
Anyone disagree?
______
Yes. Me and Noriel Roubini.
Tell me where all of this new, stupid credit is going to come from?
4th or 5th inning? Hell, we’re not even in the ballpark yet. If we do have a big rally, you’d better get in and get out.
You know what scares me is that this guy don’t get it. As he keeps dumping wads of liquidity into the economy in one form or fashion it only makes the dollar cheaper. This increases the prices of energy and food because they are denominated in dollars. Both of these are consumed by all U.S. consumers who are 70% OF the GDP. Who should we be protecting afterall, corporate America or most Americans?
I follow matters like this with interest not because I care about the world of finance for its own sake (like many of the seeming bulls in this thread), but rather because my profession makes me one of the first dogs kicked when the economy starts to go south.
Putting aside for the moment that I am in the closing weeks of my worst quarter since the year of my mother’s death (and worse than several of my 2K-’02 quarters)…
The dollar is taking it in the pants, and my understanding of macroeconomics suggests that the strength of a currency is a primary indicator of the strength of the economy in which it was issued to circulate.
Long story short, we pay others to make what we consume, and as other states amp up their knowledge economies, the relative value of the U.S. knowledge economy – that is to say, the engine of the entire U.S. economy, apart from ag and natural resources – decreases. The amount of *stuff* we can buy as a result also decreases. Where does this trend take the United States (and for a while at least, the rest of the world with it)? I really don’t like the answer to that question.
I’m not trying to be Chicken Little here, and much to my chagrin, what I’m about to write makes me sound a great deal more against free trade than is actually the case…
I can’t help but think that the next three to five years are going to be a terrific argument against the way in which globalization has been implemented. The Train of Unintended Consequences is pulling up to the platform, all aboard.
And real estate? Symptom, not disease. When you dump a bunch of money into the economy (hello? interest rates?) and need to forestall inflation, where else is it going to go? Yep! It’ll be something with enough intrinsic value that people will be grateful to take possession at any remotely-reasonable price.
The good news (as such) is that if it goes far enough, the United States will actually be able to afford to fill in the gap that twenty years ago was a robust secondary economy, and do it on terms that will put the developing nations to shame. (Either that, or those productivity advances during the Nineties looked great on paper.)
Until then, well, the rest of us’ll be standing there, holding our proverbial p*****s in our hands and paying progressively higher prices for pretty much everything. Y’all have fun with that market.
Honestly, I think we (bears) were saved by the run on Bear Stearns news today. If it was not for Bear Stearns related panic selling, more bears would be squeezed today (it was setting up as another rally for the bulls before the Bear Stearns announcement).
I happen to agree with Biggs (sorry BR). I used today’s god given panic selling opportunity to cover all my shorts.
BSC is only a $4B market cap now trading ½ book value, meaning it will be bought by someone like Buffet. Bernanke will cut by 100 bp (Lets be honest, lower rates will eventually work). There will be a joint dollar intervention. In short, as Biggs said, this is not the end of the world and not time to get wildly bearish.
What say you BR?
Keep in mind that Biggs was a strategist not a trader so his timing (even IF he is right!!!) could be off by enough time to put you in the poorhouse. Wonder how his hedge fund is doing??? anyone know the performance numbers??? I am ready to be underwhelmed. He’s a good talker but so what? show me the money from his great calls….IF OIL and Gold correct and the dollar does a dead cat intervention bounce and the fed cuts and and and Barton backs up the truck we could get a little bounce next week. But will it hold? Hell if I or anyone in the world really knows…..will be educational to observe however.
“what I’m about to write makes me sound a great deal more against free trade than is actually the case…”
I’m not against free trade either…. just haven’t come up with a correct terminology for WTF we have been about these last 7 years.
Feels like 2001 doesn’t it. March, ah March, dropped 250 K of cash into the S&P at 108.00, seemed like a good buy. Lost my ass.
There is no there, there. The S&P is 25 pct over valued, fundamentally. Yes, I agree with BBiggs, a bear market erection may happen here. My humble model has the S&P technically overvalued (not fundamentally) by 2 % on it’s way to perhaps 4 %. So what.
The markets are synthetic. No value, all calculation. Have at it boys and girls. Wealth is created by hard labor, persistence, capitalism, and populism. In the former America ( post great depression), the financial world was a tool to be used, not a business to lead wealth creation.
Now we have a piece of shit non-government Federal Reserve bailing out second rate grifters. I have not a nickel in the so called market, nor will I until it reaches value at 83 SPY.
Hello… is anyone out there……
Please tell this underground miner I’m full of shit …
Barry
It’s all about the Dollar;
The dollar should be the strongest and most stable currency in the world and we need to “hold the line”.
“Ten thousand dollars to our general use.”
William Shakespeare
Hey blam, your stuff is pretty funny, and makes a lot of sense as well. But your money must be somewhere, so where is it?
Lots of chatter about how ‘undervalued’ Citibank is. Is this legitimate or a Wall Street ploy to get investors to inject capital into a struggling bank? This blog is ridiculous, kinda like the restaurant at the end of the universe….
My money, my money
My money is like the wind – always and every where.
My money is at risk of being destroyed by the POS republicans. Unfortunately, I believe in America and have decided to stay with us.
Did I ever tell you that my wonderful father was shot in the face in WW2. Drove his tank from the front of the armored column of the 7th cavalry stopping to pick up wounded. Two silvers and a bronze. Very American micks.
There you have it. I have given up on the whole ideal of markets.
Biggs and others say get ready for a rally. okay. tell me what earnings estimates your using on the S&P and what multiple on the earnings to come up with a market price that we’ll rally to. Not saying he’s wrong but give me some analysis instead of just saying it has to rally because the world isn’t ending. okay, so the world isn’t ending, so maybe markets just go sideways for 3, 6, 12, or 24 months until valuation makes sense. ever think of that. yeah we’ll get through it but that doesn’t mean we’re due for a “rally”
Ain’t amazing how blockheads like craig behnke can step on holistic moments and not even know it.
Barry
It’s all about the Dollar;
The dollar should be the strongest and most stable currency in the world and we need to “hold the line”……….
Posted by: David | Mar 15, 2008 12:30:26 AM
WHY ??
the US has been using the USD to live off
foreign production, investment, sweat, etc, etc, ain’t going to continue
There were some mighty weighty questions being asked in that Restaurant at the End of the Universe.
But,
I don’t recall this question being asked:
“How much liability can the Fed manage?”
No one (except maybe JP Morgan) is going to be Bear Sterns ESPECIALLY Warren Buffet. Book values on companies whose asset values change daily and are 40x leveraged mean nothing. Bear Sterns holds some of the worst mortgage paper on the street and it has all plummeted in value in the past 2 months. I would put money on their book value being well below 0 at this point. maybe the fed will force JPM to buy them the same way BofA had to buy countrywide.
I noted that this morning’s front page NYT article by Landon Thomas concerning the new Bear Sterns welfare program did NOT mention the dreaded “I” word once.
This, ladies and gentleman, is what passes for “analysis” once snouts begin plunging into the public trough.
We don’t have free trade, we have petrodollar hegemony. Now the blowback from it is killing us.
The rise in oil is just an obvious clear symbol to Americans. Our real problem is the falling USD. One of the only reasons oil is up this much is because the USD has fallen 40% since the Iraq war. Just keep printing the money guys and $5.00 a gallon gas will be here by next year.
http://finance.yahoo.com/q/bc?s=DBC&t=3m&l=on&z=m&q=l&c=dba
As you can see by the chart, commodity prices took off on the day of the announcement of the stimulus package.
It is having the opposite effect that is desired. Money is flowing from the financial markets to the commodity markets creating further stress on the system.
Jay Haley, CFP